Tag Archives: Edgar Rice Burroughs

Disney does it again! How can you take one of the greatest adventures in the last 100 years and screw it up?  Yep, John Carter went Hollywood. Edgar Rice Burroughs wrote A Princess of Mars in 1917 as a love story, adventure story and most of all a story of undying friendship. I wanted the movie to reflect the incredible emotion I felt when I first read the book, unfortunately, it did not.

John Carter is a southern gentleman and a former officer of the Confederacy loaded with worthless Confederate currency and hunting for gold. In John Carter that is apparently supposed to make up for the loss of his wife and child. Carter manages to find evidence of a “Cave of Spiders,” supposedly filled with gold just waiting to be picked out of the walls. Unfortunately the Union Army wants Carter to aid them in fighting the Apaches that terrorizing the populace. He refuses, violently, manages to escape and, in a nice irony, steals the commander’s horse.

When Apaches attack the soldiers chasing Carter, finally, we see the hero. He snatches the commander from the clutches of the brutal Apache and carries him to a nearby cave. Of course, predictably, it’s the Cave of Spiders. Finding technology there Carter inadvertently transports to Mars and the adventure of two lifetimes. John Carter (Taylor Kitsch) meets the love of his life, Dejah Thoris, and Tars Tarkas a 12 foot tall green alien with 4 arms, two giant tusks and a temper to match. Up to this point the movie is pretty enjoyable.

Unfortunately, the rest of John Carter is a hodgepodge of technology, evil aliens called Therns and an ego maniacal would be Emperor of Mars called Sab Than. Someone forgot about the book, forgot about the principle of a simple story done well and instead just spent a lot of money on fluff.

John Carter is “the best swordsman on two worlds.” Tars Tarkas is the greatest strategist on Barsoom and the deadliest warrior. Kantos Kan is one of the greatest commanders and pilots on the planet. So what do we get in John Carter: a bunch of confusing confrontations with balding aliens (Therns), excessive over the top flying machines and a nutty device that apparently dissolves people. I’ve read A Princess of Mars 30 times since I was 8 and even I was thoroughly confused.

I expected Lord of the Rings, Gladiator or Braveheart style battles with John Carter and Tars Tarkas back to back killing Warhoons, Zodangans and Tharks, amid piles of bodies (this only happened once and it was the best part of the movie for me). What I got was some neat technology, creepy aliens and Star Trek transporter-like technology.

One of the most puzzling element of John Carter was the casting. There were some great picks: Lynn Collins as Dejah Thoris, James Purefoy as Kantos Kan and even Dominic West as Sab Than among others, but then there was Taylor Kitsch as John Carter. He was adequate, but without the screen presence of great action heroes. Noone steals a scene from Bruce Willis, Harrison Ford or Sean Connery. Even the evil Matai Shang (Mark Strong) managed to steal scenes from Kitsch. John Carter is one of the first and greatest action heroes. They seem to have forgotten this for John Carter, the movie.

Disney could have saved themselves a hundred million dollars, developed a “period” style action movie with flashing swords, primitive flying machines, developing friendships and a great love story and had a really good movie. Add in all the missing fight scenes from A Princess of Mars and it would have been great!

Rating 3.5 stars out of 5.

 

 


Category: News, Reviews

Recent Podcasts

Top 5 Back to School Movies

Top 5 Back to School Movies
With summer coming to an end an a chill sneaking into the night air. It can mean only one thing. Back to school!

Top 5 TV Themes

Top 5 TV Themes
It's time to change things up a bit and step away from the movies in this very special Top 5 TV Themes episode! Joining me on this trip down memory lane is Mike Ranger from Video Rangers Podcast. Listen in as we dive deep into the good and the bad of televisions most memorable themes.

Top 5 Action Scenes

Top 5 Action Scenes
Put on your helmets and fasten your seat belts, it's going to be a bumpy ride. Join the gang at Movie Madness Podcast for the Top 5 Action Scenes episode. After many tears, a few bruises and a trip to the E.

Recasting The Avengers: 80’s Edition

Recasting The Avengers: 80’s Edition
Have you ever thought "What if...?" We do all the time! And being huge Marvel and 80's fans we couldn't help but wonder?

Top 5 Favorite Movie Politicians

Top 5 Favorite Movie Politicians
With election day drawing near and honestly not a single candidate worth a darn to vote for! Who can we look to for leadership? The movies of course!!!

Top 5 Surprising Movie Deaths

Top 5 Surprising Movie Deaths
Ever been tooling along in a film and then Voila, your favorite character croaks? Well we have and oh how we hate it, but then, we're just warm and fuzzy guys. Tune in to our Top 5 Surprising Movie Deaths episode and find out our absolute horror at the death of Alan Tudyk and which movie it was.

Subscribe

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Subscribe to Podcast In iTunes


Trailer of the Week!


Sites We Like


Soiled Restroom Cinema

SRC logo

Video Rangers


The Obssessive Viewer


Two Peas On A Podcast


First to Die